LoginStatus Logout not working

I am at wits end here.

I have a loginstatus control on a master page. 

When logged in using Forms Auth,  I click LogOut and I get the following page with a bunch of jibberish in the url.

I have set the LogoutAction=RedirectToLoginPage and that did not work.

I also set the event OnLoggingOut  to a custom function and it did not get hit.

Another thing I tried was setting the LogoutAction to "Redirect" and set the LogOutPageUrl to my Login Page and that did not fire.

Any ideas?